Build Your Own Subscription

Become a Penny Pal!

Pick your Pennies, tell us how often, and we'll get to baking!

Step One

Pick your Pennies.

Can I change what's in my box?

Anytime. Swap flavors, add a bag, or change how often it ships — all from your account. Changes apply to your next batch.

Am I locked into anything?

No. Skip a shipment or cancel whenever you want, no phone call and no hoops.

What does the Club actually save me?

10% off every order plus free shipping, no minimum. That applies for as long as you're a Penny Pal.

Thanks for being one of our people. We're glad the Pennies found a home at your table.