Penny Pal Club

Build your own box.

Pick the Pennies you actually want, tell us how often, and we'll bake them fresh and send them your way. Same family recipe Grandbetty wrote down — just on your schedule.

  • 10% Off Every Order
  • Free Shipping
  • Skip or Cancel Anytime

Step One

Pick your Pennies.

Questions before you commit?

Can I change what's in my box?

Anytime. Swap flavors, add a bag, or change how often it ships — all from your account. Changes apply to your next batch.

Am I locked into anything?

No. Skip a shipment or cancel whenever you want, no phone call and no hoops.

How fresh are they?

Every box is baked small-batch to order and ships the same week. They don't sit on a shelf waiting for you.

What does the Club actually save me?

10% off every order plus free shipping, no minimum. That applies for as long as you're a Penny Pal.

Thanks for being one of our people. We're glad the Pennies found a home at your table.